The Headline that Never Was

The sinking of the RMS Titanic, as painted by ...

More myths surfaced with the sinking of the Titanic than were poor souls lost with the ill-fated liner.

Digital history has fuelled an explosion of interest – with a lot more source material available to examine online.Titanic is the focus of a huge regeneration project in Belfast and this site created by National Museums Northern Ireland is quite superb.

Some myths have stuck for nearly a century – the most durable being the famous headline attributed to the Aberdeen Press and Journal (then the Aberdeen Journal) which usually goes along these lines: “North-east man lost at sea. 1500 perish in Titanic disaster”

Alas no basis in fact – I discuss this further here in the Scottish Review.

Newspapers offices around the world were thrown into complete chaos on the night of the April 14, 1912.
To think of the sinking of the unsinkable was, frankly, unthinkable. Only four days earlier they had reported in enraptured terms the start the maiden voyage of the world’s “safest” liner.

New York dailies had the story first. The Times, under Carr van Anda’s astute editorship, got it right from the outset – the Titanic had sunk but the Evening Sun had later cause to regret its banner headline: “All Saved from Titanic after Collision.”

Among those drowned was WT Stead, the great pioneer of campaigning journalism and the source of another myth that he might have foretold the disaster in a book. The Aberdeen Journal’s editor William Maxwell would certainly have known of Stead – they had both previously worked on the Pall Mall Gazette and the Evening Standard.

Whilst national titles with due deference to the prevailing social order reported at length on the 11 millionaires who perished, it was local papers around the world who unearthed the pathetic tragedies among the 750 third class passengers, 572 of whom were drowned.

The Aberdeen Journal reported on Andrew Johnston, son of the clerk to the school board in Newmachar. A plumber in London, he, his wife and their two children were travelling with his wife’s sister’s family: “He had sold out his property and his business and determined to try his luck on the other side of the water. They had taken passage on another ship but had transferred to the ill-fated Titanic.”

All ten were drowned – with all their hopes and dreams.

The Journal also had an important local story of international interest. Among the survivors were Sir Cosmo and Lady Duff Gordon, of Maryculter, on the outskirts of Aberdeen.

English: Lucy Christiana, Lady Duff Gordon

On April 20 it carried Lady Duff Gordon’s report of panic when the lifeboats were launched: “I recall being pushed towards one fo the boats and being helped in. Just as we were about the clear the ship a man made a rush to get aboard our lifeboat. He was shot and apparently killed instantly. His body fell into the boat at our feet. No-one made any effort to move him and is body remained in the boat until we were picked up.”

Oops …. and now another myth is born. Walter Lord, the editor and copywriter whose great historical narrative A Night to Remember revived interest in the Titanic and spawned several films, saw it quite differently. He quotes Lady Duff Gordon saying to her secretary as the Titanic finally went down: “There is your beautiful nightdress gone.”

The Duff Gordons and their secretary occupied three seats out of 12 in the Number One Lifeboat which had a capacity for 40. Sir Cosmo, an Olympic silver medal winning athlete, offered crew members in the lifeboat £5 each for the kit they had lost with the ship and his wife reassembled the men in lifejackets for a group picture afterwards.

Their behaviour was certainly not in the best possible taste and they had a hard time living it down afterwards. Greg Ward, author of Rough Guide to the Titanic considers, looks at this in more detail in a two-part Blogtanic post here.

One thing’s for sure – the Titanic will continue to fascinate for another 100 years.

Categories: history on the web

Tags: , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: